Censorship In My Own Back Yard
Legal, Manga, Misc, News, Western News May 1st, 2008Tags: censorship, Dark-Horse, oregon
Tags: censorship, Dark-Horse, oregon

So, one of the things I love about Oregon (besides the fact that Portland has the highest number of strip clubs per capita of any city in the country, including Vegas) is the fact that we have some of the broadest interpretations of “freedom of speech” of any state in the union. (As a result, I’ve always wondered why so many anime and manga companies are situated in Texas instead of Oregon.)
However, I didn’t know that back in July, a law was passed that was supposed to forbid the sale of any sexually explicit material to a minor if the material was meant to “satisfy a sexual desire.” However, apparently local bookshops and publishers found the law to be too broad, however, and feel that it criminalizes titles that would otherwise be acceptable. For example, the law could be interpreted such that any book that contained information about sex, like a textbook, might be illegal to sell to minors.
The manga-related news is that Dark Horse has joined the group of stores and pubs suing the state over the law. A few other plaintiffs include Powell’s (remember them?), the Comic Book Legal Defense Fund, and interestingly, Planned Parenthood.
(P.S. Link via Journalist.)
| View blog authority | ![]() Stumble it! | Share |
May 1st, 2008 at 11:37 am
Another good reason to relocate to Oregon.
Seriously I’ve actually considered moving to Oregon once.
May 1st, 2008 at 11:40 am
@DrmChsr0: It’s a great state. You do have to be willing to put up with grey days for most of the year though.
May 1st, 2008 at 2:32 pm
A similar law is being instated in the UK, but it is way too broad… hell, James Bond matches its criteria to be illegal… orz
Times are changing and I am hoping this gets a turnover….
May 1st, 2008 at 3:30 pm
I have to throw my hat into the ring and say pip-pip bally-ho well done to the plaintiffs in this one. The first thing that the company CMX did that pissed me off, back when it started, was to edit the hell out of Tenjou Tenge. Keep in mind that this is a series that I have never read, nor plan to read, but it disturbs me that the company thinks they have the prerogative to “cover up” the “inappropriate” parts of the book. My suggestion would be to simply market the book the way it was intended. Were I an author who had this done, I feel it would come as a slap in the face, and a clear sign that the company doesn’t care about preserving the original work of art.
The second part of this rant concerns those lovely stickers so nicely displayed above. Dark Horse at least has the common sense and decency to make them weakly adhesive and covered in plastic wrap, so I can at least take the damn things off when I get them home. However, it dismays me to see that they are occasionally printed permanently on the cover of other companies’ books. Think about this for a minute, and you’ll realize the flaw in logic; how many of you are encouraged to buy a product, involving handing it to the teenage or elderly (there never seems to be a middle ground for some reason) cashier at the local bookshop when there is a large sticker on it declaring, in effect, “THE PERSON HOLDING THIS BOOK IS CLEARLY SOME SORT OF SEXUAL DEVIANT!” And that really doesn’t look so great on the bookshelf, either. Now, I know some of you are saying “But I don’t care if people think I’m a sexual deviant!” But the point here is that it is not the job of the government to tell you what you should and shouldn’t read. I would rather not live in a society wherein everything is stapled to a disclaimer. So good for you, Oregon!
May 2nd, 2008 at 5:12 pm
Speaking of Dark Horse, I live right next to their little main HQ in Milwaukie.